Plaintiffs press 2nd Circ. to revive Chinese vitamin C antitrust case

 Two U.S.-based companies that purchase vitamin C from sources abroad urged a federal appeals court on Tuesday to revisit a panel decision that shut down an antitrust lawsuit claiming Chinese e xporters had unlawfully conspired to fix the price and supply of the nutrient.

A 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel in August ordered the dismissal of the lawsuit against Chinese companies Hebei Welcome Pharmaceutical Co Ltd and North China Pharmaceutical Group Corp. The panel judges, voting 2-1, concluded there was a "true conflict" between U.S. and Chinese antitrust law that meant the defendants could not comply with U.S. legal provisions.

In their petition seeking en banc review or panel rehearing, lawyers for Texas-based Animal Science Products Inc and New Jersey-based Ra nis Co Inc argued that the panel decision, if left in place, "invites judicial micromanagement of foreign policy powers reserved to the political branches."

William Isaacson of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, did not immediately respond to a message on Wednesday seeking comment. Isaacson represents the plaintiffs with lawyers from Willkie Farr & Gallagher, Hausfeld and Susman Godfrey.

Jonathan Jacobson of Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, who represents the Chinese company defendants, told Reuters on Wednesday that "the petition r aises nothing remotely problematic with the court's decision."

Circuit Judge William Nardini, joined by Circuit Judge Jose Cabranes, concluded in the panel ruling that Chinese law required Hebei Welcome and North China Pharmaceutical "to engage in price-fixing of Vitamin C sold on the international market."

Relevant Chinese regulations "required the defendants to collude on Vitamin C export prices and quantities as part and parcel of China's export regime for Vitamin C," Nardini wrote.

Circuit Judge Richard Wesley wrote the dissent, which disputed the majority's conclusion that Chinese law required the defendants to coordinate on the price of vitamin C exports.

Isaacson and co-counsel for the plaintiffs asserted in their petition that the panel decision crafted a new test – without congressional support – to assess whether a key U.S. antitrust law reaches conduct overseas.

"Absent further review, the panel decision vests courts with virtually unbounde d discretion to rewrite duly enacted statutes based upon judicial speculation about foreign policy," the plaintiffs' lawyers wrote.

The case is Animal Science Products Inc v Hebei Welcome Pharmaceutical Co Ltd, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 13-4791.

For the plaintiffs: William Isaacson of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison; Michael Gottlieb of Willkie Farr & Gallagher; Michael Hausfeld of Hausfeld; and James Southwick of Susman Godfrey

For the defendants: Jonathan Jacobson of Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati

Chinese vitamin C price-fixing lawsuit thrown out by U.S. appeals court

Related Posts

• Folic acid is to be added to the most commonly consumed flours in the UK to help prevent spinal conditions in babies Folic acid is to be added to the most commonly consumed flours in the UK to help prevent spinal conditions in babies, the government has announced.Doctors… Read More
• TV presenter Julia Bradbury reveals she has breast cancer The television presenter Julia Bradbury has announced she has breast cancer, and urged other women to check their breasts and seek help if they notice any cha… Read More
• How often should we exercise to get in shape? Elite athletes—like Jakob Ingebrigtsen, who won gold for the men's 1500m race at the Tokyo 2020 Olympics—train almost ten to 14 times per week, clocking up … Read More
• 5 Home Remedies for Managing the Itch of Atopic Dermatitis For many people dry, itchy skin is the main — and most troublesome — symptom of atopic dermatitis, a type of eczema. But scratching can irritate skin and make… Read More
• 5 Skincare Swaps to Make for FallAs the days get shorter and the temperatures creep lower, your skin needs warm and cozy layers, too. Come fall, products with gentle, hydrating formulas help pr… Read More